Best Rated Upper East Side NYC Plastic Surgeon Reviews

At our Upper East Side plastic surgery practice in NYC, we pride ourselves on giving patients the best in quality care and results. Our reviews speak for themselves:

“Dr. Mahmood was incredibly professional and made me feel very comfortable throughout my free consultations. She is not only an expert in her field, but also very good at communicating each step of the way and of being prescriptive regarding post-procedure care. I look forward to coming back as her patient in the future.I am so happy with my liposuction and fat transfer.” ~ Google

“Where do I even start about this amazing Doctor!? I had considered a breast augmentation with breast implants and a breast lift for years and met with numerous doctors but never felt like I was heard. I searched the internet for “best breast plastic surgeon in NYC” and found her. I met with Dr. Umbreen Mahmood and almost instantly knew she was MY plastic surgeon! She spent so much time with me, truly listening and offering advice. One of the hardest things for me was picking a size. She spent over an hour with me, trying on implants, explaining why one might be better than the next and never once seemed annoyed with my perpetual indecisiveness. The day of my plastic surgery she was so calm and reassuring that I had zero nerves. I also can’t say enough good things about her anesthesiologist and nurse. I’m currently 7 weeks post op and my breast look incredible! Prior to surgery, I was an A cup. I had breast fed and my small breasts had become even smaller and deflated. Now trying on bikinis and backless dresses is SO fun! I wish I could personally talk to everyone considering Dr. Mahmood, because I know how hard it is to put such a major surgery in someone else’s hands, but I can absolutely assure you there is no one better! She is the absolute best breast surgeon in NYC! Simply talking to her for 5min and you’ll just know. She totally just “gets it!” Besides that she is a total perfectionist, excited and passionate about her work and up to date on all the latest surgical procedures. I also really appreciated how personal she was. I was never dealing with a secretary or a PA, she would personally email and call me herself and has been in constant contact throughout my healing process. There aren’t enough words to thank her or describe what a talented breast plastic surgeon and wonderful person she is. Rest assured your search is over! You have found the best” ~Yelp

“From my preop to postop Dr. Mahmood has been spectacular every step of my liposuction journey in NYC. She returns emails & phone calls immediately despite her hectic schedule, no question was too minor (especially coming from me where everything’s an emergency) She is the best plastic surgeon in NYC and her level of professionalism & honesty helps you achieve your body goals long after the surgery im complete”~ Healthgrades

“I was considering a breast augmentation with breast implants for as long as I realized I had breasts. I noticed early on at around 12 that both breasts were developing at a different pace and was advised by my doctors that in time they would catch up to each other. That simply never happened. So I decided to have breast implants plastic surgery. I went to one male Surgeon that made me feel comfortable with the info he provided during a consult but something told me to continue shopping for a doctor. The moment I met Dr Mahmood I felt instantly confident. I knew she was the best plastic surgeon in NYC. I decided to allow Dr Mahmood to pick a size and type of implant for me. I can’t brag enough about what she’s done for me mentally, emotionally and physically! She is a true visionary, artist, professional, personable and a rapid responder. It’s been over a year since my surgery and this Doctor still keeps in touch.”~RealSelf

“Dr. Mahmood is an extraordinary surgeon to work with! I had the opportunity to film and document a patient journey with her and was taken back by not only her knowledge, but how much she genuinely cares about her patients. Being someone that’s traveled all over the country to shoot for an array of clients she by far has to be one of my favorites and for patients looking for a plastic surgeon they can truly feel comfortable with, I’d highly recommend looking no further than Dr. Mahmood for liposuction fat transfer.” ~ Google


“I am a 37 year old female with kids and I was shaped like a box, no joke. After years of wanting to build the courage of getting a tummy tuck I started researching plastic surgeons. After searching for the best plastic surgeon in NYC I came upon Dr. Mahmood profile and decided to have a consultation. Is she the first? No… but she was the last! I received my tummy tuck, liposuction in the back and liposuction in my chin and I am so HAPPY. This doctor is GOD SEND. She is sweet, caring, gentle and patient! Boy is she patient. Every question is answered. She’s HONEST and realistic which is sooooo important when making a life change. I love her. I have never dealt with any doctor that has given me the comfort as she has. I also want to mention this is a real review. I am a real patient and i gain nothing from reviewing, this doctor is simply THE BEST THERE IS!”~ Healthgrades

“Dr. Mahmood is the best and just amazing! It was my first time getting under eye fillers and she talked me through the entire process. She is very knowledgeable and takes her time during the procedure. I had little to no swelling or bruising after the procedure, the fillers look amazing. Her expertise and her ability to make you feel at ease really helped throughout the entire process. I highly recommend seeing Dr. Mahmood, you won’t be disappointed.~RealSelf

“Dr. Mahmood is fantastic. She is very pleasant, and goes above and beyond to meet a patients expectations. Dr. Mahmood is extremely skillful and precise. I still can not believe the beautiful results of the mommy makeover that she performed on me. I call her my “miracle worker” because the results of the procedure was an absolute miracle for me, far beyond what I expected. I definitely recommend Dr. Mahmood for any plastic surgery procedures in NYC.” ~ Healthgrades

“I have gotten my lip filler done multiple times from the top NYC plastic surgeon, Dr. Mahmood and seriously – she is amazing!!! She is very educated, professional, and goes through each step of what she is doing. She listens to your needs and makes the whole experience very easy and comfortable. I would 100% recommend Dr. Mahmood for anyone interested in the best injections in NYC. My lips have never looked better!! She is also one of the best at injectables – BOTOX.” ~ Yelp

“Delighted to recommend Dr. Umbareen Mahmood! I’m excited by my new-improved upper abdomen at only one month after liposuction and can’t wait to see what changes future weeks bring. Procedure itself was relatively quick and the Upper East Side NYC office is stylish and comforting. I always felt well cared for.~RealSelf

“Dr. Mahmood is a skilled surgeon, clear communicator, and really an artist with her work. Plastic surgery is as much art as it is science, and this superwoman has all the talent, enviable diligence, and an obvious passion for what she does. She defies the essence of how every doctor should be; upon meeting her I was greeted with a warm smile. She took the time to patiently answer all of my questions & concerns. On the day of the labiaplasty procedure she reassured me and out my mind at ease. I was beyond satisfied with the results from my procedure. I highly recommend her to all patients looking for a excellent plastic surgeon”~Healthgrades

“My experience with Dr. Mahmood was absolutely fantastic! I am 24 years old and I had been wanting to have a breast reduction for at least 8 years. I suffered from terrible back pain as I’m only 5’2 and wore a size 34E. The entire process went smoothly from the initial consultation the my final post-op visit. Dr. Mahmood walked me through everything and helped calm my nerves along the way. I am about a year post-op and thrilled with the results. My breast look very natural and fit my frame perfectly!” ~ Google

“It has been almost a year since my plastic surgery come May. I’m still loving my thigh lift plastic surgery results. Dr. Mahmood is the best, love her bedside manner. I feel the best I have ever felt. I never felt more comfortable with myself. She made a huge difference. It took years to make this decision, her work has met my expectations. All questions were answered before asking, a little nervous but the staff made me feel comfortable. So far, good. Highly recommended.”~ Healthgrades

“I discovered Dr. Mahmood online as I was searching for an expert in the area of breast implants / breast augmentation. I was astonished and quite impressed by the number of incredible reviews she had and meeting her in person confirmed everything her patients had to say about her. Dr. Mahmood took her time explaining the whole process to me patiently, thoroughly and efficiently. She is very knowledgeable and intelligent and an expert in terms of her performance. She used the 3D imaging she has in her office to demonstrate how my breasts will look after the surgery using different sizes of implants. I had my implants 4 months ago and I could not be more thrilled with my results. My recovery was very smooth with no complications and I was able to go back to my busy job (as a lawyer) in 4 days following my operation.” ~ Google

“I am 15 days post-op today! If this was the end result I’d be very happy. For anyone reading this review and still in the research phase of their procedure. Its worth emphasizing how important it is to choose a surgeon that you genuinely like (NOT just because their price is right , they have good photos or their schedule is free) . Keep in mind not only are they operating on you but you’ll stay in touch 1 day, 1 week, 3 weeks, 3 months, 6 months + post plastic surgery. Dr Mahmood’s office is pure bliss. Its on the Upper East Side of Manhattan and is enormous. The waiting room has beautiful large windows, nice furniture and the other clientele are friendly and quiet. The staff is wonderful and i’m always seen on time. These finer details are important and will shape your experience overall. Breast augmentation surgery isn’t just the 2hr surgery itself. Its the months (or years!) of research, weeks of healing and months of check-ins and follow-up-appointments.”~ RealSelf

“Dr. Umbareen Mahmood is a wonderful physician and plastic surgeon. She filled my lips with fillers  to make them larger while keeping them natural looking. She also did the best job making my wrinkles disappear with Dysport. While getting my routine botulinum I also consulted Dr. Mahmood on getting a breast reduction and liposuction. After a number of other consultations I am absolutely positive that she is the best plastic surgeon for the job.”~ Healthgrades

“For years I contemplated breast augmentation with breast lift. After finally making the decision to do so, I had to find the best plastic surgeon in NYC who had a proven track record and expertise, and could make me feel comfortable about the entire process, and through a trusted friend Dr. Mahmood was highly recommended as the best of the best. From the first consultation visit Dr. Mahmood was absolutely amazing! She was patient with me, answered all of my questions, and really assured me.”~ Healthgrades

“I had a lot of apprehensions going into my breast augmentation. I was an athlete all my life, started lifting weights early in life & never developed a chest. Completely flat & always felt like I needed to wear a bra under a sports bra to feel like a woman. I didn’t want to have my boobs done to have big boobs. I just wanted to look like the best version of myself. I even expressed over and over in my appointments with her that I wanted to look as natural as I could. I wanted no one to be able to tell that I had a surgery. I am very happy and have the best outcome!”~ Healthgrades

A consultation is necessary to determine which plastic surgery procedure is right for you. During your consultation with the board certified plastic surgeon at our Upper East Side location in NYC, Dr. Umbareen Mahmood will work with you to help you achieve your goals. Contact us today to book your consultation with Dr. Mahmood at our Upper East Side location and be one step closer to your plastic surgery goals.

Our plastic surgery practice is dedicated to protecting your health and helping you achieve your cosmetic plastic surgery goals by providing superior patient care every step of the way, from the first consultation through the recovery period. We believe in making plastic surgery a comfortable fit for your budget and offer a variety of flexible financing options, including CareCredit™. Our in-office patient coordinator is happy to work with you to find a compatible payment option.

Umbareen Mahmood, MD
Upper East Side (Manhattan, NYC) Plastic Surgeon
5 E 57th St, Floor 16
New York, NY 10022
(917) 426-2936

Request a Consultation

Contact us

Awards and Media